Review: ‘Wuthering Heights’ Review: A Stunning Romance That Misses a Crucial Layer

Directed by Emerald Fennell, the 2026 adaptation of Wuthering Heights is undeniably beautiful. Fennell’s lush visuals, heightened emotions and aesthetic control transforms Yorkshire to a dreamlike landscape. The deliberate contrast between the Linton Estate and Wuthering Heights not only highlights class division, but shapes the audience’s perception of where Catherine “belongs.”

The cinematography captures both the beauty and brutality of the setting. Margot Robbie delivers a captivating Catherine, balancing fragility with determination. Robbie perfectly captures Catherine’s internal conflict of freedom with her desire for social security. Jacob Elordi brings an intensity and vulnerability to Heathcliff, making their on-screen chemistry magnetic. As a romantic tragedy, the film is emotionally immersive and captivating.

As a standalone film, this adaptation is exceptional. It functions as a sweeping gothic romance, drawing audiences into a story of obsessive love and heartbreak. However, the casting of Elordi significantly alters the story’s weight. In Emily Brontë’s novel, Heathcliff’s racial ambiguity is central to his rejection. His difference in race and social status intensifies the barrier between him and Catherine. Fennell’s adaptation reduces the hard-hitting thematic issues, shifting the conflict more toward class and pride rather than systemic prejudice due to race.

Ultimately, the film is visually masterful, yet while the breathtaking color and lighting illustrate class divides, it softens the novels’ deeper racial otherness. Overall, Wuthering Heights is a haunting and elegant on-screen adaptation that captivates the senses, even if it does not fully confront the novel’s most uncomfortable truths.